Life is like a box of cookies...

You don't choose the cookies. The cookies choose you.

TCM Cookie's cake batter cookies available to pickup in Tampa or ship nationwide.

salted caramel cookies with a brownie center

The Cookie Mystery Box

From $19.00 Save { sale }%

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Choose Amount: Box of 3

Box of 3
Half Dozen
Dozen

SKU N/A

Quantity

Every box is a surprise, and that’s the fun! The Cookie Mystery Box is the ultimate flavor roulette box from TCM Cookie. Each box is a surprise selection of our gourmet cookies, thick, chewy, and loaded with personality. You won’t know what’s inside until you open it… but trust us: you’ll be glad you did.

FAQ

Q: What cookies are in the box?
A: It’s a surprise! You’ll receive an assorted mix of our signature gourmet cookies. No two boxes are exactly the same.

Q: Can I pick my flavors?
A: Nope — that ruins the fun. Cookie Mystery means no substitutions and no customizations.

Q: Are these cookies fresh?
A: Always. We bake to order in small batches and ship fast so you get the full TCM Cookie experience.

Q: When will my order ship?
A: Orders ship within 3–5 business days. You’ll get a tracking number once your cookies are on the way.